X f R ✉︎
// LINK COPIED //

Resident Evil Requiem Is My Game of the Year, and I’ve Never Been Happier to Be Wrong

Leon Kennedy from behind on a rain-soaked Raccoon City street at night, a bloody hatchet in his hand, bodies on the pavement around him

I actually hate RE7 and RE8...

If you’ve read any of my blogs, you already know this, and you’re probably tired of hearing about it. But I don’t hate them because they’re bad games. I hate them because they’re bad Resident Evil games. RE8 comes a little closer, but both of them lose track of what makes Resident Evil special in the first place, and that’s why I despise them.

We can argue all day about whether Resident Evil was always pure survival horror or always survival action-horror. (I already wrote that blog. It’s long. You can find it.) But RE7 and RE8 aren’t bad Resident Evil games for what they are. They’re bad Resident Evil games for what they’re not.

RE8 gets partial credit. Over-the-top villains and action set pieces are everywhere in that game, so it comes a tiny bit closer. But both of them fall flat on the one thing that separates Resident Evil from every other survival horror game on the shelf:

Character.

Ethan Winters doesn’t become a character until the last twenty minutes of his second game. That means you follow a guy with no personality, and literally no face, for two entire games before he gets interesting. Never, not once, in a single mainline Resident Evil game, has that been the case. Hell, even in the Outbreak games, where you play as everyday average Joes, every single one of them had something that made them unique and capable. A cop. A doctor. A plumber with a toolbox. A reporter who could pick a lock.

(Remember the reporter. We’ll come back to her.)

Ethan is just a guy, and he never becomes more than just a guy. No personality. No attitude. No understanding of the horrors going on around him. Literal cardboard, concrete, and plastic.

Ethan Winters ruins RE7 and RE8. Put any previously established Resident Evil character in his place, tell any other story, and we’d be talking about dramatically better games.

But that all sounds like biased hyperbole from a guy who has admitted, time and time again, that he despises RE7 (and, to a lesser extent, RE8). So how can you take his opinion for anything?

Well, you can’t. My opinion means jack shit.

So let’s look at Resident Evil Requiem instead. Let’s look at why I went from dreading its release to thinking it’s one of the top three games in the entire franchise, what it does right that 7 and 8 did wrong, and how it created a brand new character without throwing the old ones in the dumpster.

I Love Being Wrong

In October of last year, I wrote that RE9 was “looming on the horizon looking more like RE7, or even Silent Hill, than the ‘roots’ Capcom insists it’s returning to.” I wrote that my personal canon ended at RE6, and that I’d “mourned the series ever since.”

I wasn’t even planning on buying it. I’d already chucked it into the bargain-bin corner of the franchise with Survivor, Gaiden, and Umbrella Corps, never expecting to give it a shot.

Oh, great. Another nobody we’ve never heard of, running around terrified, with no survival skills and no character beyond “man look for wife, man find wife in bad place, man survive.” Plus an original, beloved character as a cameo who shows up for thirty seconds with a new face and no purpose.

(Or, in the case of RE8’s Chris Redfield, a stupid idiot who could have stopped the entire game from happening if he’d just told Ethan, who had zero reason not to believe him, by the way, that his wife was an evil monster lady who wanted their daughter. Like, seriously, Chris. WTF? The whole game could’ve been avoided, and you wouldn’t have looked like a villain, if you’d just said, “Ethan, remember the mold shit? This isn’t Mia. Trust me.” But no. We needed a plot more than we needed characters. Anyway…)

Where was I? Oh, yeah.

Grace Ashcroft crouched in a dark hallway with a lighter and a small flashlight, her shirt bloodied, looking down at a body under a sheet

Everything I saw about RE9 was built around a trembling, terrified girl with no survival skills whatsoever, running through dark hallways from a monster with nothing but a lighter. The same thing you can find in literally any three-dollar Steam horror game, right now, at this very second.

RE7 all over again. Ah, we’re scared! That’s good, right? That’s what you wanted? But look! MONSTERS! It must be Resident Evil.

I can go over what Resident Evil truly is over and over and over again. But “nobodies running from monsters” has NEVER been Resident Evil. Not once.

RE1? A special ops team. The horror came from the unknown, not from the characters’ weakness. RE2? A rookie cop and a highly trained college student. The horror came from being thrown into the blender, not from the characters’ weakness. RE3? Jill Valentine, with everything she survived in the mansion, trying to escape the city she knew…

You know what? It doesn’t matter. No one listens.

But Resident Evil was NEVER about nobodies trying to survive. Even Ark Thompson from Survivor was a freaking secret agent. Even in Outbreak, one of your playable characters was an RPD officer. The whole “Resident Evil has always been this way, we’re back to form, blah blah blah” crowd has never played one of the original three games. And if they have, they weren’t paying attention.

So the trailers told me exactly what we were getting. Another average Joe dealing with horror.

Yay?

But unlike RE8, I gave it a shot anyway. With no Ethan in sight, I figured maybe, just MAYBE, there was some chance things would be different.

And yeah. They were very different.

Leon FUCKING Kennedy

You have to remember how little we knew going in. Leon was only very, very, very sparsely teased in the marketing for this game. Up until the last few weeks, we were all under the impression he’d be an RE7 Chris (shudders) level cameo.

So when you start the game and realize you actually get to play as him, everything changes.

You get a taste of him early. But then comes about an hour of Grace being tormented by a ten-foot-tall monster girl, stumbling through dark hallways with a lighter… and then the game hands you Leon. In an arena-style surgery room. Full of zombie doctors with chainsaws.

And you fist fight them. You pistol whip them. You butterfly kick them.

Leon Kennedy in his leather jacket raising a pistol at zombies shambling toward him down a foggy, rain-soaked city street

Yeah. That was when I knew this was a Resident Evil game.

I specifically remember shouting “OH MY GOD, IT’S A RESIDENT EVIL GAME!” while it was happening, at max volume, with a smile on my face.

Leon has never been my favorite Resident Evil character. But for the first time since RE6, we got to watch a Resident Evil character do Resident Evil stuff, and we were the ones controlling it, and it was FUN. Chris got to do some stuff in RE8, but it’s arguable whether that was even Chris Redfield, based on the decisions he makes in that game. In RE9, we get to be Leon FUCKING Kennedy, roundhouse kicking dudes with chainsaws.

We’re back to RE4. RE5. RE6. Revelations. It finally feels like Resident Evil again.

The sigh of relief I let out after that scene was immense. It felt like an old dead friend coming back to life. And for the first time since I played RE7, I had hope for this franchise.

Going from Grace’s terror to Leon’s pew-pew-wahbam felt exactly like the Resident Evil I remember, and everything I’d been saying for years felt vindicated.

Resident Evil was whole again.

Resident Evil 6 Already Wrote the Manual

RE6 does something really well that nobody will willingly give it credit for: it introduced three brand new characters, and it did it very, very well.

Where RE7 failed Ethan most (and failed itself as a result) is that it threw him into the horror without any Resident Evil spine. A brand new character, with brand new horrors, in a brand new place, seemingly disconnected from the rest of the franchise. There wasn’t a single recognizable character until the last thirty seconds of the game. (Unless you count Alyssa Ashcroft’s name on a newspaper. Hold that thought, too.)

So a franchise built on thirty years of iconic characters threw us into a game with a guy in a khaki jacket who shows no emotion, has no personality, and never shows us his face. That’s it. That’s what you get. Then, at the very end, you get an abomination from the pits of hell called Chris Redfield from Temu, and everybody calls it a Resident Evil game. GG. Game of the Year. Greatest Resident Evil of all time (by many accounts).

RE6 didn’t do that. RE6 gave you three new characters, and paired every one of them on equal footing with a character we already knew and loved. It didn’t just say, “Here’s Helena, get to know her.” It didn’t say, “Here’s Piers, good luck.” It didn’t say, “Here’s Wesker’s kid, have fun.” (Though Jake honestly could’ve stood on his own, just on the strength of being the son of the greatest villain in the franchise.)

No. It paired them with Leon, Chris, and Sherry. And it did it well enough that you never feel like the icons got erased or ignored, and you never have to force yourself to like the new guy just because he’s the only one you’re allowed to play. You learn to appreciate them over the course of the story, because they’re interacting with the world we already know.

RE7 never does that. RE8 does it sparingly.

RE9 went to the RE6 school of new characters and graduated with honors.

Leon Kennedy, battered and sitting in the rubble, looking up at a bloodied Grace Ashcroft

Splitting the game between Grace and Leon, letting them actually interact with each other, and making each of them play completely differently is brilliant. Literally brilliant. It creates hills and valleys, in the emotion and in the gameplay, that feel legitimately different from one another. Both experiences stay unique, and neither character ever feels less important than the other.

And by the end, you realize Grace was never special. Which makes it even better, because it gives the “every Resident Evil character was an average Joe” crowd exactly what they wanted. Grace really was a nobody. The only reason she made it as far as she did is because she was scared shitless and kept fighting anyway.

And Leon kept fighting because he’s Leon, and Leon do what Leon do.

By the time the credits roll, you’ve played as Leon, you’ve seen Sherry, you’ve merced zombies left and right, and you’ve run from horrible abominations as Grace through a hospital that might be one of the greatest sections in the history of the franchise.

RE9 introduced a new character without forgetting about its iconic ones. 7 and 8 couldn’t manage that without either shoving the icons into the background or making them stupid.

Oh, and Zach? You said telling Leon’s story would be “redundant and… disappointing.”

Capcom told Leon’s story. It was neither.

Scared to Death, and Saddling Up Anyway

Creating a new character in a thirty-year-old franchise has to be one of the hardest things to pull off. On one side, you get people like me in the Ethan situation: old curmudgeons who’d rather eat glass than play him, who see right through cardboard character creation and need more. On the other side, you get people like me in the Grace situation, where she becomes my second favorite character in the history of the franchise.

I think that makes me the perfect example of both extremes, because I can tell you exactly why one worked for me and one didn’t.

Grace is the one that worked.

First and foremost, Grace never feels like the star of this game, and I mean that in the best way possible. She’s a girl caught up in a huge mess she wants no part of, and she reads that way from the start. She’s tied to it because her mother died because of it. And her mother is Alyssa Ashcroft. Yes, THAT Alyssa Ashcroft. The reporter from Outbreak who could pick a lock. (Told you we’d come back to her.)

But Grace isn’t the star. She’s a POW of sorts, thrown in and expected to survive. The real star of this game is Leon, the game reads that way, and that’s good for Leon AND for Grace.

Grace not being the star makes her infinitely more vulnerable. Knowing Leon is out there somewhere gives you the feeling she could die at any moment, even while you’re the one playing her. There’s a scene where I legitimately thought her foot got chopped off, and I believed it, because she was so vulnerable that it was believable. Her not being the star made her feel expendable. At any second, this could become Leon’s game.

But damn, did she play that part well…

I have never fallen in love with a character so fast.

I don’t want this whole blog to be an Ethan attack. (It is a little bit an Ethan attack.) But I never cared about Ethan until the last thirty minutes of his second game. I had no reason to. The dude poured some liquid over his severed leg, stuck it back on, and never blinked. He showed no emotion in a single scene of fear or danger. His wife was so unlikeable that saving her felt less like a goal and more like a chore. And the choice near the end, between saving her and the other chick, had no bearing on anything and made no sense.

Then there’s Grace. Grace shows emotion and personality from the very first scene she’s in.

Close-up of Grace Ashcroft's face in a dim room, worried and uncertain

She’s clumsy. She’s nervous. She is not at all cut out for the job she’s been handed. When she’s scared, it is HEAVILY emoted, to the point that some people called her unrealistically scared. When the lights cut out, she yelps. She stutters when she talks. In third person, she stumbles when she runs. She sweats. She is legitimately feeling the horror going on around her. And next to the Leon gameplay, where we’re basically Rambo-ing zombies into oblivion, you get the true contrast between real fear and a professional who has seen this shit before.

John Wayne said courage is being scared to death and saddling up anyway. Grace is that quote. And it isn’t just an idea the game tells you about. She’s shown to be terrified. When Emily gets taken down into the underground, Grace has a panic attack, a real, visible reaction to how terrifying it is… and she goes down anyway. Because it’s the right thing to do, and Emily is more important than her fear.

That’s the mark of a great character. She shows us her emotions instead of making us assume them, and that makes her exactly what a new character in an old world should be: tied to the world we love, and fitting into it like she was always there.

I’ve said before that nobody pays three hundred dollars for a statue of a vibe. There’s a quarter-scale Grace Ashcroft on my shelf.

A Grace Ashcroft statue: Grace lounging in a red leather wingback chair beside a lamp and side table, a revolver in her gloved hand

She is not a vibe.

If Jill Valentine weren’t the love of my life, Grace would be my new favorite Resident Evil character. (Jill is still number one. That’s never changing.)

Raccoon City, All These Years Later

I’ve played every Resident Evil game. Including the bad ones. Including the really bad ones.

I started in the mansion, and I wasn’t brave enough to finish it. I went to the RPD with Leon and Claire, and I still wasn’t brave enough. Jill Valentine is the one who finally gave me the strength to beat RE3, and I overcame my fear through her, countless times, before I ever went back and finished the other two.

The Tyrants. The man-eating plants. The zombie dogs. The four-barreled rocket launchers. The sewer gator. The Hunters jumping twelve feet in the air just to take my head off. The electrocuted shark in the REmake. The giant bats, the giant centipedes, the Plagas bursting out of people’s necks in RE4 and RE5. The giant axe-swinging Executioner. Giant… well… Giants, in the El Gigantes. I went to Spain. Africa. Battleships. Floating cities.

I did it all.

And there’s a moment in this game where I had to stop playing long enough to leave the house and breathe some air.

Returning to Raccoon City all these years later, and seeing it destroyed, wasn’t just a gaming experience. It was an emotionally jarring one.

Have you ever seen a friend after twenty years apart and not known what emotion to feel? It’s somewhere between recognition and forgetting. Between knowing who that person was, and knowing they’re probably not the same person you called a friend all those years ago. People change. Places change. But you see them again, and you remember everything from back then, and you realize that’s enough. You don’t need who they are now to be who they were then, because that version of them was yours to keep forever, and that version of you was theirs.

There’s something comforting about that. People change, but memories keep them a certain way.

That’s what it felt like returning to Raccoon City.

Leon walking through the rubble of destroyed Raccoon City toward the burned-out shell of the RPD building under a grey sky

Look. There’s a lot of discourse in fandoms about how things need to change to fit modern audiences. About how you need to stop caring so much, because it’s just fiction. It isn’t real. Why do you care so much that Welcome to Raccoon City made Leon a long, dark-haired Indian dude who’s clumsy and inept? He’s just a fictional character. Why do you care if the new Resident Evil movie has nothing to do with the games? Look, it has a green herb, and monsters, and the city’s called Raccoon City!

But the truth is, it all matters. Every last bit of it.

When you’ve spent thirty years with a franchise, when you’ve had posters of the characters on your wall, when you’ve cosplayed them or bought their guns or dreamt about them, when you’ve kept thirty-year-old magazines just because they have maps of the games in them, these things matter. They matter more than “get a new game out.” They matter more than “name it Resident Evil and they’ll buy it.”

These things MATTER.

And RE9 understands that.

Walking through destroyed Raccoon City literally felt like being haunted by a ghost. (In my opinion, it’s actually the weakest stretch of the game, right up until you get to the RPD. We’ll get there.) I was uncomfortable. The atmosphere, the fact of what it was, the memories… it was all so surreal. Maybe even uncanny.

And once you get to the RPD? Incredible. The Tofu easter egg. The PS1 with Mega Man and Street Fighter Alpha 2 sitting there, right next to a copy of the original Resident Evil. (In Raccoon City. I see you, Capcom.) The Barry and Chris references. The Tyrant’s return. It was all just the right kind of fan service, and it was done gloriously.

A dusty old console in the ruins with a controller, a scratched Resident Evil disc, Mega Man 8, and cases for Street Fighter Alpha 2 and the original Resident Evil

Then there’s Zeno, the Wesker clone, tying straight back to the RE6 story and making RE9 feel like the first ACTUAL Resident Evil sequel since 6. The new lab. The descent into it. All of it was absolutely glorious, fantastically done, and impervious to any criticism I might otherwise have had.

Best Horror Game vs. Game of the Year

In my Hellraiser blog, I said Hellraiser: Revival might be the greatest horror game I’ve ever played. I meant it, and I still mean it. I even said it beats RE9 as a horror game.

So how is Requiem my Game of the Year?

Well…

I’ve said before that Seven Samurai is probably the greatest movie ever made, and I never want to rewatch it, while I’d watch Street Fighter (2026) again right this second. “Greatest” and “favorite” aren’t the same thing. Sometimes the best game isn’t the best game. (Which is probably why The Game Awards nominated GTA VI for Game of the Year before it was even out.) Sometimes how a game makes us feel, what it has to show us, or our personal ties to it, are what make it the best.

Requiem wasn’t the best horror game I played this year. But it was definitely the best game I played this year.

It erased the faults of the past. It took me back to the place I grew up in. It brought back the feeling I’ve had playing these games my entire life. It introduced a new character who isn’t just likeable, but who doesn’t overshadow the icons, and doesn’t even try to. It blew away every expectation I had for enemy variety (and coming from the guy who still calls RE7 the game with the least enemy variety he’s ever seen, that means something). It ties together storylines from RE1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. And it feels like the first mainline Resident Evil game since RE6.

Which was, hold your breath, FOURTEEN YEARS AGO.

It logically brings all of it together into an ACTUAL sequel, for the first time in a decade and a half.

It shows love to something I love greatly, and it breathes new life into it. It does everything right on both sides, the action AND the horror. And I simply love it, because it makes me feel like the people who made it are just like me.

Is It Perfect? No. Hellraiser Wasn’t Either.

Of course it has weaknesses.

Zeno should have been a bigger threat. Digging into him should have revealed a lot more about Wesker’s clones. The Emily bit in the orphanage fucking sucks. The final boss fight was mostly forgettable. And the Raccoon City stretch runs a bit too long before you hit the RPD.

But for everything it does wrong, it does three or four things right.

Requiem

Last year, I said my personal canon ended at RE6, and that I’d mourned this series ever since.

I’m amending that.

A requiem is a mass for the dead. And I’d been holding one for Resident Evil for a long, long time. Then Capcom made a game called Requiem, sent me back to Raccoon City, and handed me Leon Kennedy, Sherry Birkin, Wesker’s ghost, and Alyssa Ashcroft’s daughter, all in the same story.

Grace Ashcroft in a brown leather jacket and backpack, looking back over her shoulder in a snowy, ruined city

Turns out, in Raccoon City, the dead don’t stay down.

For bringing something I love back from the grave, Resident Evil Requiem is my Game of the Year.

OH MY GOD, IT’S A RESIDENT EVIL GAME.

« BACK TO ALL ENTRIES